Home » ભાગવતે ‘ઇન્ડિયા’ અને ‘ભારત’ વિશે ખરેખર શું કહ્યું હતું?

ભાગવતે ‘ઇન્ડિયા’ અને ‘ભારત’ વિશે ખરેખર શું કહ્યું હતું?

by Jaywant Pandya

[polldaddy poll=6813167]હમણાં મોહન ભાગવતનાં બે નિવેદનોએ ખળભળાટ મચાવી દીધો. સંઘની માનસિકતા વિશે ભરપૂર ટીકાઓ થઈ. જેઓ સંઘને નજીકથી નથી જાણતા અથવા જેમનો નાતો સંઘની વિચારસરણી સાથે નિયમિત રીતે નથી રહેતો તેવા લોકોય ભ્રમમાં મૂકાઈ ગયા. ભાગવતે ‘ઇન્ડિયા’ અને ‘ભારત’ વિશે ખરેખર શું કહ્યું હતું? શું તેમણે એવું કહ્યું હતું કે ગ્રામીણ ભારતમાં બળાત્કારો નથી થતા અને શહેરી ‘ઇન્ડિયા’માં થાય છે? તેમણે આપેલું પ્રવચન મને હિન્દીમાં (તેમણે હિન્દીમાં જ પ્રવચન આપ્યું હતું) મળ્યું છે તે અક્ષરશ: કોઈ પણ ફેરફાર વગર અહીં ‘પેસ્ટ’ કરું છું. આ પ્રવચનની યૂટ્યૂબની લિંક પણ અહીં મૂકું છું. આ જોઈને જ નક્કી કરો કે ભાગવત સાચા કે તેમના નિવેદનને મારીમચડીને રજૂ કરનારાં માધ્યમો સાચાં?
असम के सिल्चर में प्रबुद्ध नागरिकों के साथ हुए वार्तालाप कार्यक्रम में उपस्थित एक सज्जन ने डा. भागवत से प्रश्न पूछा, ‘‘ये जो इंडिया में आजकल जो अट्रॉसिटीज अगेन्स्ट विमेन, रेप्स, मॉलेस्टेशन बढ़ रहे है, इनमें हिंदुओंपर ज्यादा अत्याचार होते दिख रहे है। यह हिन्दुओंका मानोबल नष्ट करने का प्रयास लग रहा है। इसके संदर्भ में आपके क्या विचार हैं?’’

इस प्रश्न के उत्तर में डा. भागवत ने कहा – ‘‘इंडिया में जो यह घट रहा है, बढ़ रहा है वह बहुत खतरनाक और अश्लाघ्य है। लेकिन ये भारत में नहीं है। यह इंडिया में है। जहां इंडिया नहीं है, केवल भारत है वहां ये बातें नही होती, आज भी। जिसने भारत से नाता तोड़ा उसका यह हुआ। क्योंकि यह होने के पीछे अनेक कारण हैं। उसमें एक प्रमुख कारण यह भी है कि हम मानवता को भूल गये, संस्कारों को भूल गये। मानवता, संस्कार पुस्तकों से नहीं आते, परंपरा से आते हैं। लालन-पालन से मिलते हैं, परिवार से मिलते है, परिवार में हम क्या सिखाते है उससे मिलते हैं।
पारिवारिक संस्कारोंकी आवश्यकता
दुनिया की महिला की तरफ देखने की दृष्टि वास्तव में क्या है?दिखता है की, महिला पुरुष के लिए भोगवस्तु है। किन्तु वे ऐसा बोलेंगे नहीं। बोलेंगे तो बवाल हो जाएगा। किन्तु मूल में जा कर आप अध्ययन करेंगे तो महिला उपभोग के लिए है, ऐसा ही व्यवहार रहता है। वह एक स्वतंत्र प्राणी है, इसलिए उसे समानता दी जाती है। किन्तु भाव वही उपभोग वाला होता है। हमारे यहां ऐसा नहीं है। हम कहते हैं कि महिला जगज्जननी है। कन्याभोजन होता है हमारे यहां, क्योंकि वह जगज्जननी है। आज भी उत्तर भारत में कन्याओंको पैर छूने नहीं देते, क्योंकि वह जगज्जननी का रूप है। उल्टे उनके पैर छुए जाते हैं। बड़े-बड़े नेता भी ऐसा करते हैं। उनके सामने कोई नमस्कार करने आए तो मना कर देते हैं,स्वयं झुक कर नमस्कार करते हैं। वो हिंदुत्त्ववादी नहीं है। फिर भी ऐसा करते हैं। क्योंकि यह परिवार के संस्कार हैं। अब यह संस्कार आज के तथाकथित एफ्लुएन्ट परिवार में नहीं हैं। वहां तो करिअरिझम है। पैसा कमाओ, पैसा कमाओ। बाकी किसी चीज से कोई लेना-देना नहीं।
शिक्षा में मानवता के संस्कार होने आवश्यक
शिक्षा से इन संस्कारों को बाहर करने की होड़ चली है। शिक्षा व्यक्ति को सुसंस्कृत बनाने के लिए होती है। किन्तु आजकल ऐसा नहीं दिखता। शिक्षा मानवत्त्व से देवत्त्व की ओर ले जाने वाली होनी चाहिए। किन्तु ऐसी शिक्षा लगभग शिक्षा संस्थानों से हटा दी गई है। समाज में बड़े लोगों को जो आदर्श रखने चाहिए वो आदर्श आज नहीं रखे जाते। उसको ठीक किया जाना चाहिए। कड़ा कानून बिलकुल होना चाहिए। इसमें कोई दो राय नहीं है। कड़ी सजा दोषियों को होनी ही चाहिए। इसमें कोई दो राय नही है। फांसी की होती है तो हो। विद्वान लोग विचार करे और तय करे। लेकिन केवल कानूनों और सजा के प्रावधानों से नहीं बनती बात। ट्रॅफिक के लिए कानून है मगर क्या स्थिति होती है?जब तक पुलिस होती है, तब तक कानून मानते है। कभी-कभी तो पुलिस के होनेपर भी नहीं मानते।जितना बड़ा शहर और जितने अधिक संपन्न व सुशिक्षित लोग उतने ज्यादा ट्रॅफिक के नियम तोड़े जाते हैं। मैं कोई टीका-टिप्पणी नहीं कर रहा हूं। केवल ऑब्जर्व कर रहा हूं। मैं विमान में बैठा था। पास में एक सज्जन बैठे थे। मोबाइल पर बात कर रहे थे। विमान का दरवाजा बन्द हुआ। किन्तु उनकी बात बन्द नहीं हुई। एअर होस्टेस चार बार बात बन्द करने के लिए कह गई। इनके लगातार फोन काल आ रहे थे। अबकी बार एअरहोस्टेस को आते हुए देख वे भड़क उठे और कहने लगे, ‘२८ इंजिनिअरिंग संस्थानोंमें डिसिप्लिन रखने का जिम्मा मेरे उपर है, और आप मुझे डिसिप्लिन सिखा रही है! ’अब अगर २८ संस्थाओं में डिसिप्लिन रखने की जिम्मेदारी जिस पर है, वह एरोप्लेन में दी जानेवाली सामान्य सूचनाओं का पालन नहीं करता तो उसे हम क्या कहे?इसके विपरीत हमारे वनवासी क्षेत्रों में चले जाएं। जहां अनपढ लोग हैं, गरीब लोग हैं। उनके घर का वातावरण देखो। कितना आनन्द होता है। कोई खतरा नहीं। बहुत सभ्य, बहुत सुशील। (वहां परंपरा, परिवार की शिक्षा कायम है। शहरों में) शिक्षा का मनुष्यत्त्व से नाता हमने तोड़ दिया इसीलिए ऐसा होता है।
बिना संस्कार कानून असरदार नहीं
कानून और व्यवस्था अगर चलनी है, उसके लिए मनुष्य पापभीरू होना है, तो उसके लिए संस्कारोंका होना जरूरी है। अपने संस्कृति के संस्कारों को हमें जल्द जीवित करना पड़ेगा। शिक्षा में कर लेंगे तो परिस्थिति बदल पाएंगे। तब तक के लिए कड़े कानून, कड़ी सजाएं आवश्यक है। दण्ड हमेशा होना चाहिए शासन के हाथों में और वह ठीक दिशा में चलना चाहिए। वह इन सबका प्रोटेस्ट करने वालों पर नहीं चलना चहिए। उसके लिए उनका संस्कार भी आवश्यक है। वो वातावरण से मिलता है। पर वो भी आज नहीं है। हम यह करें तो इस समस्या का समाधान पा सकते हैं।
मातृशक्ति है भोगवस्तु नहीं
हमारी महिलाओं की ओर देखने की दृष्टि वे मातृशक्ति है यही है। वे भोगवस्तु नहीं,देवी हैं। प्रकृति की निर्मात्री है। हम सब लोगों की चेतना की प्रेरक शक्ति है और हमारे लिए सबकुछ देनेवाली माता है। यह दृष्टि जब तक हम सबमें लाते नहीं तब तक ये बातें रुकेगी नहीं। केवल कानून बनाने से काम नहीं चलेगा। वो होना चाहिए किन्तु उसके साथ संस्कार भी होने चाहिए।’’

આ લેખ આપને ગમ્યો? આ વેબસાઇટ પર આવા લેખો વાંચવા મળતા રહે તે માટે સપૉર્ટ કરો.
અહીં ક્લિક કરો.

You may also like

2 comments

અશોક મોઢવાડીયા 07/01/2013 - 5:59 PM

આભાર.

’केवल कानून बनाने से काम नहीं चलेगा। वो होना चाहिए किन्तु उसके साथ संस्कार भी होने चाहिए।’

Reply
PH Bharadia 08/01/2013 - 6:40 PM

A full translation in English for benefit of English readers,thanks Jayvant Bhai Pandya.

Interactions with Silchar in Assam enlightened citizens event, Dr. Bhagwat A gentleman asked the question,” these days which Atrositij Against Women in India, reps, Molesteshn is growing, much of these atrocities are looking Hinduonpr . It looks Hinduonka attempt to destroy morale. In this context, what are your thoughts?”

In response to this question, Dr. Bhagwat said -” It’s happening in India is growing very dangerous and is Aslagy. But it is not in India. It is in India. While India is not only India, there are not these things, even today. He was the one who broke ties with India. There are several reasons behind it. It is a major reason that we forgot to humanity, forgotten rituals. Humanity, values ​​do not come from books, come from tradition. Upbringing meet, meet the family, the family is what we teach to meet him.
Family needs Snskaronki
Women of the world in terms of looking at what looks, women to men is Bhogvshu. But they do not speak. So will speak organically. But be original if you will study for women consume the same behavior. He is an independent creature, so it is equality. But the price is the same consumption. We do not do that. We say that the woman is Jagzznni. We Knyabhojn is because he is Jagzznni. Even today in India Knyaonco feet do not touch, because it is a form of Jagzznni. Touched his feet are inverted. Large – Senior leaders do the same. If someone came to greet him refuse, greet bow down themselves. He does not Hinduttwwadi. Still do. Because it is family values. Now these values ​​are not in today’s so-called Fluant family. So there is Kriarijm. Earn money, earn money. Nothing else to do – nothing.
Education must be the values ​​of humanity
These values ​​have gone from education to out race. Education is to create a cultured person. But nowadays it is not. Manwattv education should be to move towards Dewattv. But such education has been almost removed from educational institutions. Keep older people in society who should ideally placed as the norm today. He should be fine. All laws must be tightened. There are no two opinions. The guilty must be punished severely. There are no two opinions. If death occurs. Scholars to consider and decide. But it does not only to the provisions of laws and punishment. What is the law for traffic, but unless you have the police, the law is considered. Occasionally the police do not cause sunburn. Much more affluent and well-educated people as much as the big city and traffic rules are broken. I have no comment’m not. ‘m Just observe. I was sitting in the plane. Nearby sat a gentleman. Talking on mobile. Aircraft door is closed. But they did not stop talking. Air Hostess call four times to close the deal. They were constantly coming to call. They come to see this time hostess broke out and saying, ’28 Injiniaring Snsthanonmen on me the responsibility to keep discipline, and discipline is teaching me! “Now you have the responsibility to keep discipline in 28 institutions, the general information to be given in Aroplen it does not follow what can we say go contrary to our aboriginal areas. Where people are uneducated, poor people. See their home environment. How much fun is. No risk. Very polite, very nice. (The convention, family education is sustained. Cities) we broke away from education Mnushyttv why this happens.
Not work without the sacrament law
Law and order is the sieve, for him to be Papbiru humans, so it is important to be Snskaronka. Soon we will have to live the values ​​of our culture. After learning the situation will change. Rules for long, stiff sentences is necessary. Punishment should always be in the hands of government and in the right direction to go. Protest must for all those who walk on it. Their culture is also essential for him. She meets environment. But they do not have today. If we can find a solution to this problem.
Do not Bhogvshu Matriskti
Toward our vision of women is that they have Matriskti. They are not Bhogvshu, Devi. Nature of the producer. Consciousness is the prime mover of all of us and is mother to us all lending. Until this point until we bring in all these things will not stop. The law will not work. But it should also be cremated with him.”

Interactions with Silchar in Assam enlightened citizens event, Dr. Bhagwat A gentleman asked the question,” these days which Atrositij Against Women in India, reps, Molesteshn is growing, much of these atrocities are looking Hinduonpr . It looks Hinduonka attempt to destroy morale. In this context, what are your thoughts?”

In response to this question, Dr. Bhagwat said -” It’s happening in India is growing very dangerous and is Aslagy. But it is not in India. It is in India. While India is not only India, there are not these things, even today. He was the one who broke ties with India. There are several reasons behind it. It is a major reason that we forgot to humanity, forgotten rituals. Humanity, values ​​do not come from books, come from tradition. Upbringing meet, meet the family, the family is what we teach to meet him.
Family needs Snskaronki
Women of the world in terms of looking at what looks, women to men is Bhogvshu. But they do not speak. So will speak organically. But be original if you will study for women consume the same behavior. He is an independent creature, so it is equality. But the price is the same consumption. We do not do that. We say that the woman is Jagzznni. We Knyabhojn is because he is Jagzznni. Even today in India Knyaonco feet do not touch, because it is a form of Jagzznni. Touched his feet are inverted. Large – Senior leaders do the same. If someone came to greet him refuse, greet bow down themselves. He does not Hinduttwwadi. Still do. Because it is family values. Now these values ​​are not in today’s so-called Fluant family. So there is Kriarijm. Earn money, earn money. Nothing else to do – nothing.
Education must be the values ​​of humanity
These values ​​have gone from education to out race. Education is to create a cultured person. But nowadays it is not. Manwattv education should be to move towards Dewattv. But such education has been almost removed from educational institutions. Keep older people in society who should ideally placed as the norm today. He should be fine. All laws must be tightened. There are no two opinions. The guilty must be punished severely. There are no two opinions. If death occurs. Scholars to consider and decide. But it does not only to the provisions of laws and punishment. What is the law for traffic, but unless you have the police, the law is considered. Occasionally the police do not cause sunburn. Much more affluent and well-educated people as much as the big city and traffic rules are broken. I have no comment’m not. ‘m Just observe. I was sitting in the plane. Nearby sat a gentleman. Talking on mobile. Aircraft door is closed. But they did not stop talking. Air Hostess call four times to close the deal. They were constantly coming to call. They come to see this time hostess broke out and saying, ’28 Injiniaring Snsthanonmen on me the responsibility to keep discipline, and discipline is teaching me! “Now you have the responsibility to keep discipline in 28 institutions, the general information to be given in Aroplen it does not follow what can we say go contrary to our aboriginal areas. Where people are uneducated, poor people. See their home environment. How much fun is. No risk. Very polite, very nice. (The convention, family education is sustained. Cities) we broke away from education Mnushyttv why this happens.
Not work without the sacrament law
Law and order is the sieve, for him to be Papbiru humans, so it is important to be Snskaronka. Soon we will have to live the values ​​of our culture. After learning the situation will change. Rules for long, stiff sentences is necessary. Punishment should always be in the hands of government and in the right direction to go. Protest must for all those who walk on it. Their culture is also essential for him. She meets environment. But they do not have today. If we can find a solution to this problem.
Do not Bhogvshu Matriskti
Toward our vision of women is that they have Matriskti. They are not Bhogvshu, Devi. Nature of the producer. Consciousness is the prime mover of all of us and is mother to us all lending. Until this point until we bring in all these things will not stop. The law will not work. But it should also be cremated with him.”

Reply

Leave a Comment